CO129-080 - Sir Robinson - 1861 [1-3] — Page 473

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

24

407

policy to place the Cantonment in such a position as to interfere as little as possible with the interests of the former, and be as far removed as possible from the influence of the latter. Under these circumstances I cannot agree to the plan proposed by the Commanding Royal Engineer, I admit that the site chosen is in many respects suited to the purpose, and no objection would exist to its occupation if any other site could be availed of for Civil purposes; but other site does exist, while for Military purposes other, and in my opinion better, sites for Cantonment are available on the promontory of Kowloon or, taking it for granted that that one site now proposed is the only one, and if that deprives the Mercantile interests of the advantages it naturally looked for in the occupation of the Promontory, is it not desirable to consider the whole question as to the disposal of Troops, and avail, say of the open land referred to at West Point, or to that more open at Pokefulum originally chosen by General Straubenzee for a Sanatorium?

I believe that either site would be found eminently healthy and by such an occupation the present exorbitant demands for space in Kowloon would be materially reduced, the Troops in no way inconvenienced, the trade not driven from the plain, and I consider that taking into consideration the circumstances connected with Kowloon an area of 50 acres is ample for all Military

Edit History

2026-05-18 22:34:10 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
24 407 policy to place the Cantonment in such a position as to interfere as little as possible with the interests of the former, and be as far removed as possible from the influence of the latter. Under these circumstances I cannot agree to the plan proposed by the Commanding Royal Engineer, I admit that the site chosen is in many respects suited to the purpose, and no objection would exist to its occupation if any other site could be availed of for Civil purposes; but other site does exist, while for Military purposes other, and in my opinion better, sites for Cantonment are available on the promontory of Kowloon or, taking it for granted that that one site now proposed is the only one, and if that deprives the Mercantile interests of the advantages it naturally looked for in the occupation of the Promontory, is it not desirable to consider the whole question as to the disposal of Troops, and avail, say of the open land referred to at West Point, or to that more open at Pokefulum originally chosen by General Straubenzee for a Sanatorium? I believe that either site would be found eminently healthy and by such an occupation the present exorbitant demands for space in Kowloon would be materially reduced, the Troops in no way inconvenienced, the trade not driven from the plain, and I consider that taking into consideration the circumstances connected with Kowloon an area of 50 acres is ample for all Military
Baseline (Original)
24 407 policy to place the Cantonment in such a position as to interfere as little as possible with the interests of the former, and be far. removed as possible from the influence of the latter. agree lender these circumstances ICaunot lan now to the plan proposed by the... Commanding Royal Engineer, I admit possible objection no that the site chosen is in many respects suites to the purpose, and no would exist to its occupation if any other site. but Conex be availed of for Civil purposes; other site does exist, while for Military purposes other, and in my opinion better, sites for Cantonment are available on the promontory of Kowloon or taking it for granted that that one site now proposed is the only one, a and if that deprives the Mercantile interest- of the advantages it naturally looked for in the occupation of the Promontory, is it not desirable to consider the whole question as to the disposal of Troops, and avail, say of the open land. referred to at West Point, or to that more open at- | Pokefulum originally chosen by General ~ Straubenzee for a Sanatorium ? I believe that either site women be found eminently healthy and by such an occupation the present exorbitant demands for space in Kowloon would be materially- reduced, the Troops in no way inconvenienced : the trade not driven from the plane. and I Consider that taking into consideration the circumstances Connected with Kowloon an area of 50 acres is ample for all Military
2026-05-18 22:34:10 · Baseline
View content

24

407

policy to place the Cantonment in such a

position as to interfere as little as possible with

the interests of the former,

and

be

far.

removed as possible from the influence of the

latter.

agree

lender these circumstances ICaunot

lan now

to the plan

proposed by the...

Commanding Royal Engineer, I admit

• possible objection

no

that the site chosen is in many respects suites to the purpose, and no

would exist to its occupation if any other site.

but Conex be availed of for Civil purposes; other site does exist, while for Military purposes other, and in my opinion better, sites for Cantonment are available on the promontory of Kowloon or taking it for granted that that one site now proposed is the only one,

a

and

if that deprives the Mercantile interest- of the advantages it naturally looked for in the occupation of the Promontory, is it not desirable to consider the whole question as to the disposal of Troops, and avail, say of the open land. referred to at West Point, or to that more open at- | Pokefulum originally chosen by General ~

Straubenzee for a Sanatorium ?

I believe that either site women be

found eminently healthy and by such an occupation the present exorbitant demands for space in Kowloon would be materially- reduced, the Troops in no way inconvenienced : the trade not driven from the plane.

and

I

Consider that taking into consideration

the circumstances Connected with Kowloon

an area of 50 acres is ample for all Military

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.